Vacation Rentals in Plum Island, NJ: Compare 10+ Sites & Save

AirbnbBooking.comVrboExpediaKayakTripadvisorHotels.comAgoda.com
  1. VBOR
  2. Vacation Rentals
  3.  USA

  4.  New Jersey

  5.  Plum Island

Refine your search

Price per night

Amenity Filter

Rating

113 Best Vacation Rentals in Plum Island (Starting from $159)

Little Haven
Little Haven
House
Plum Island, Highlands, New Jersey, USA
0.6k from Plum Island center

Cheap, Accommodations, Parking, Villas, Vacation homes, Cottages, Pet-friendly, Lodgings, Vacation rentals

5 Bedrooms11 Guests
8.8

Fabulous

24 reviews

$216
Average price / night
Check Availability
Little Haven (D)
Little Haven (D)
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.3k from Plum Island center

AC, Barbecue, Crib, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Microwave, Outdoor Grill

2 Bedrooms5 Guests
8.8

Fabulous

23 reviews

$263
Average price / night
Check Availability
Stunning Bayfront Sandy Hook Retreat Views and Yard
Stunning Bayfront Sandy Hook Retreat Views and Yard
House
Atlantic Highlands, NJ, USA
3.1k from Plum Island center

Wheelchair Accessible, Parking, View, Pool, Internet, Ocean View

2 Bedrooms6 Guests
New to Booking
$353
Average price / night
Check Availability
Little Haven (B) — Bungalows, Private Beach
Little Haven (B) — Bungalows, Private Beach
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.5k from Plum Island center

AC, Barbecue, Crib, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Microwave, Patio

3 Bedrooms6 Guests
8.8

Fabulous

24 reviews

$263
Average price / night
Check Availability
Middletown Township Home, Close to Beaches!
Middletown Township Home, Close to Beaches!
House
NJ, USA
6.9k from Plum Island center

Accommodations, Parking, Villas, Vacation homes, Cottages, Lodgings, Vacation rentals, Places to stay, Family

3 Bedrooms5 Guests
9.0

Fabulous

1 reviews

$552
Average price / night
Check Availability
SPECTACULAR OCEAN VIEW BEACHFRONT RENOVATED 2BR
SPECTACULAR OCEAN VIEW BEACHFRONT RENOVATED 2BR
Apartment
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.5k from Plum Island center

AC, Balcony, Barbecue, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Living Area

2 Bedrooms4 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

13 reviews

$413
Average price / night
Check Availability
Updated Downtown Red Bank Home 5 Mi to Beach!
Updated Downtown Red Bank Home 5 Mi to Beach!
House
Red Bank, NJ, USA
8.5k from Plum Island center

Accommodations, Parking, Villas, Vacation homes, Cottages, Pet-friendly, Lodgings, Vacation rentals, Places to stay

8 Bedrooms16 Guests
New to Booking
$477
Average price / night
Check Availability
Waterfront Escape! NYC Ferry, Beach, Modern New Construction 3 bedroom 3 bath
Waterfront Escape! NYC Ferry, Beach, Modern New Construction 3 bedroom 3 bath
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.6k from Plum Island center

AC, Balcony, Barbecue, Dryer, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry

3 Bedrooms8 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

1 reviews

$403
Average price / night
Check Availability
Long Branch Home Less Than 1 Mi to Beach!
Long Branch Home Less Than 1 Mi to Beach!
House
Long Branch, NJ, USA
9.2k from Plum Island center

Cheap, Accommodations, Parking, Villas, Vacation homes, Cottages, Lodgings, Vacation rentals, Places to stay

3 Bedrooms7 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

2 reviews

$983
Average price / night
Check Availability
Sandy Hook Private Beach Front Cottages
Sandy Hook Private Beach Front Cottages
Cottage
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.6k from Plum Island center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Extra Bed, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Living Area

2 Bedrooms4 Guests
9.4

Superb

29 reviews

$159
Average price / night
Check Availability
Room near the beach and shopping 13
Room near the beach and shopping 13
House
Long Branch, NJ, USA
9.9k from Plum Island center

Air Conditioner, View, Internet, Parking, Security/Safety, Child Friendly

6 Bedrooms12 Guests
New to Booking
$270
Average price / night
Check Availability
 Coastal Home With 360 Degree Rooftop Deck ~ Outstanding Views!
Coastal Home With 360 Degree Rooftop Deck ~ Outstanding Views!
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.6k from Plum Island center

AC, Balcony, Barbecue, Dryer, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry

2 Bedrooms5 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

32 reviews

$579
Average price / night
Check Availability
BEACHHOUSE SUITE BEACH AND KAYAKS IN BACKYARD
BEACHHOUSE SUITE BEACH AND KAYAKS IN BACKYARD
Apartment
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.6k from Plum Island center

AC, Balcony, Barbecue, Dryer, Extra Bed, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen

1 Bedroom3 Guests
9.8

Exceptional

10 reviews

$338
Average price / night
Check Availability
LUXURY BEACHFRONT 1BR SUITE OCEAN VIEWS PVT DECK
LUXURY BEACHFRONT 1BR SUITE OCEAN VIEWS PVT DECK
Apartment
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.6k from Plum Island center

AC, Arcade, Balcony, Barbecue, Dryer, Extra Bed, Free Parking, Heater, Internet

2 Bedrooms3 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

2 reviews

$479
Average price / night
Check Availability
BEACHFRONT 1BR WATERVIEWS WITH DECK PRIVATE BEACH
BEACHFRONT 1BR WATERVIEWS WITH DECK PRIVATE BEACH
Apartment
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.6k from Plum Island center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Living Area

1 Bedroom3 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

2 reviews

$362
Average price / night
Check Availability
Wonderful home next to shore, parks, NYC ferry!\n\n
Wonderful home next to shore, parks, NYC ferry!\n\n
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.7k from Plum Island center

AC, Balcony, Dryer, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, No Smoking, Patio

3 Bedrooms10 Guests
New to Booking
$454
Average price / night
Check Availability
Cozy 2-bedroom house in soothing Highlands, steps away to the Bay!
Cozy 2-bedroom house in soothing Highlands, steps away to the Bay!
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.7k from Plum Island center

AC, Heater, Laundry, Living Area, No Smoking, Washer

2 Bedrooms8 Guests
New to Booking
$266
Average price / night
Check Availability
WingSong of Highlands near the Bay/ocean/Seastreak Ferry
WingSong of Highlands near the Bay/ocean/Seastreak Ferry
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.8k from Plum Island center

AC, Dryer, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Living Area, Microwave

2 Bedrooms4 Guests
9.6

Exceptional

18 reviews

$247
Average price / night
Check Availability
Cozy Jersey Shore Cottage near Sandy Hook Beach - OPEN YEAR-ROUND
Cozy Jersey Shore Cottage near Sandy Hook Beach - OPEN YEAR-ROUND
Cottage
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.8k from Plum Island center

AC, Balcony, Dryer, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Living Area, Microwave

1 Bedroom2 Guests
9.6

Exceptional

20 reviews

$264
Average price / night
Check Availability
Charming 2-bedroom shore cottage with free parking
Charming 2-bedroom shore cottage with free parking
Cottage
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.8k from Plum Island center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Microwave

2 Bedrooms4 Guests
9.8

Exceptional

12 reviews

$363
Average price / night
Check Availability
NYC to ZEN -  Walk to Beach, Ferry, & Restaurants + Hot Tub, Firepit, & Gym
NYC to ZEN - Walk to Beach, Ferry, & Restaurants + Hot Tub, Firepit, & Gym
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.9k from Plum Island center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Fitness Equipment, Free Parking, Heater, Hot Tub, Internet, Kitchen

2 Bedrooms4 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

4 reviews

$420
Average price / night
Check Availability
Seashore Town - quaint one bedroom apartment
Seashore Town - quaint one bedroom apartment
Apartment
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.9k from Plum Island center

AC, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Living Area, Microwave, No Smoking, TV

1 Bedroom2 Guests
9.8

Exceptional

21 reviews

$280
Average price / night
Check Availability
Open EASTER wk: Group Friendly JerseyShore Walk to beach.restaurants & NYC Ferry
Open EASTER wk: Group Friendly JerseyShore Walk to beach.restaurants & NYC Ferry
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.9k from Plum Island center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Fireplace, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry

3 Bedrooms6 Guests
9.8

Exceptional

34 reviews

$552
Average price / night
Check Availability
NJ Paradise Tiki Hut, 5 mins to NYC Ferry and beaches!
NJ Paradise Tiki Hut, 5 mins to NYC Ferry and beaches!
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.9k from Plum Island center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Fireplace, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry

4 Bedrooms11 Guests
9.6

Exceptional

18 reviews

$558
Average price / night
Check Availability
Bright & Stylish ShoreHouse w King Beds, 15min Walk to Beach, 2 Blocks to Dining
Bright & Stylish ShoreHouse w King Beds, 15min Walk to Beach, 2 Blocks to Dining
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
0.9k from Plum Island center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Living Area

4 Bedrooms10 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

2 reviews

$1183
Average price / night
Check Availability
Brand new home by ferry, beach, shops, and trails
Brand new home by ferry, beach, shops, and trails
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
1.0k from Plum Island center

AC, Crib, Dryer, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Microwave

3 Bedrooms6 Guests
8.4

Very Good

6 reviews

$594
Average price / night
Check Availability
Lovely, spacious home at the start of Jersey Shore\n\n
Lovely, spacious home at the start of Jersey Shore\n\n
House
Highlands, NJ, 07732, United States
1.0k from Plum Island center

AC, Dryer, Heater, Internet, Laundry, No Smoking, Washer

4 Bedrooms15 Guests
New to Booking
$519
Average price / night
Check Availability

Pro Tip:
VacationByOwnerRentals aggregates the best inventory from leading travel sites, including Booking.com, Agoda.com, Expedia.com, Vrbo.com, and Airbnb.com. Use our Advanced Filters to compare verified homes, villas, cabins, condos, cottages, vacation rentals, hotels, and eco-friendly stays. Our goal is to help you find the absolute best Vacation Rentals in Plum Island.

Where to stay in Plum Island? Best neighborhoods & areas

Plum Island Vacation Rentals on the Map

Frequently Asked Questions

You can explore 113 verified vacation rentals in Plum Island. Our listings are sourced from a range of trusted providers, giving you access to a wide selection of private homes, apartments, and unique stays—all in one place.

Vacation rental prices in Plum Island vary depending on the season, property size, and location. Rates typically start from around $159 per night, with higher prices for larger homes or peak travel periods. Comparing available options can help you find a stay that matches both your budget and travel plans.

Most vacation rentals in Plum Island include fully equipped kitchens, making it easy to prepare meals and enjoy a more flexible stay. This is especially useful for families, longer stays, or travelers who prefer a home-like experience.

Yes, many vacation rentals in Plum Island welcome pets. Currently, 28 listings allow pets, although specific policies may vary by property. You can filter for pet-friendly options to quickly find suitable accommodations.

For popular travel periods such as holidays or peak seasons, it’s recommended to book your vacation rental 60 to 90 days in advance to secure the best options. During quieter times, you may still find good availability closer to your travel dates.

Vacation rentals in Plum Island often include amenities such as Fireplace/Heating, View, and Bedding/Linens. These features provide added comfort and convenience, making them a popular choice for travelers seeking more space and privacy.

You can use filters to narrow down your search by criteria such as number of bedrooms, guest ratings, or specific amenities like private pools or beachfront access. This makes it easier to find a property that fits your exact needs and preferences.