Vacation Rentals in Bay Street Theatre, NY: Compare 10+ Sites & Save

AirbnbBooking.comVrboExpediaKayakTripadvisorHotels.comAgoda.com
  1. VBOR
  2. Vacation Rentals
  3.  USA

  4.  New York

  5.  Sag Harbor
  6.  Bay Street Theatre

Refine your search

Price per night

Amenity Filter

Rating

875 Best Vacation Rentals in Bay Street Theatre (Starting from $270)

Heated Pool, Grill, Breakwater by RoveTravel
Heated Pool, Grill, Breakwater by RoveTravel
House
Bay Street Theatre, Sag Harbor, New York, USA
0.8k from Bay Street Theatre center

Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Villas, Vacation homes, Cottages, Lodgings, Vacation rentals, Places to stay

3 Bedrooms6 Guests
New to Booking
$3014
Average price / night
Check Availability
Sag Harbor 2BR Townhome w/Patio, Smart Home & Boat Slip
Sag Harbor 2BR Townhome w/Patio, Smart Home & Boat Slip
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.1k from Bay Street Theatre center

Dryer, Heater, Internet, Laundry, No Smoking, Washer

2 Bedrooms4 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

1 reviews

$1265
Average price / night
Check Availability
queeen room
queeen room
House
Bay Street Theatre, Sag Harbor, New York, USA
1.1k from Bay Street Theatre center

Internet, Oceanfront, Balcony/Terrace, View, Ocean View, Air Conditioner, Private Beach

1 Bedroom3 Guests
9.0

Fabulous

1 reviews

$270
Average price / night
Check Availability
Charming Sag Harbor Apartment. Two blocks from Main and Bay Streets.
Charming Sag Harbor Apartment. Two blocks from Main and Bay Streets.
Apartment
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.2k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Balcony, Dryer, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, No Smoking, Patio

1 Bedroom2 Guests
New to Booking
$1114
Average price / night
Check Availability
Coves Bay Beauty
Coves Bay Beauty
House
Sag Harbor, NY, USA
1.7k from Bay Street Theatre center

Laundry, Wheelchair Accessible, Pool, Parking, Internet, Child Friendly

5 Bedrooms10 Guests
New to Booking
$3853
Average price / night
Check Availability
Luxury 1BR Townhouse in Sag Harbor • Walk to Dining & Waterfront
Luxury 1BR Townhouse in Sag Harbor • Walk to Dining & Waterfront
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.2k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Dryer, Fireplace, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Living Area, Microwave

2 Bedrooms5 Guests
New to Booking
$595
Average price / night
Check Availability
Villa Kimaal - Luxury with pool
Villa Kimaal - Luxury with pool
Villa
Sag Harbor, NY, USA
1.8k from Bay Street Theatre center

Luxury, Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Villas, Vacation homes, Cottages, Lodgings, Vacation rentals

5 Bedrooms8 Guests
New to Booking
$5693
Average price / night
Check Availability
 fantastic 2-bedroom apartment deck and water view in walk to village Sag Harbor
fantastic 2-bedroom apartment deck and water view in walk to village Sag Harbor
Apartment
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.3k from Bay Street Theatre center

2 Bedrooms4 Guests
New to Booking
$581
Average price / night
Check Availability
Villa KeyLime
Villa KeyLime
Villa
Sag Harbor, NY, USA
2.0k from Bay Street Theatre center

Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Villas, Vacation homes, Cottages, Lodgings, Vacation rentals, Beach

5 Bedrooms9 Guests
New to Booking
$1241
Average price / night
Check Availability
The Cooper-Burke House
The Cooper-Burke House
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.3k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Dryer, Fireplace, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Living Area

1 Bedroom4 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

30 reviews

$430
Average price / night
Check Availability
Villa Guldan - Luxury with pool
Villa Guldan - Luxury with pool
Villa
Wainscott, NY, USA
2.7k from Bay Street Theatre center

Luxury, Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Villas, Vacation homes, Cottages, Lodgings, Vacation rentals

7 Bedrooms17 Guests
New to Booking
$2693
Average price / night
Check Availability
Pool/5 min walk to Beach/Restaurants/Museums- Village House w/backyard
Pool/5 min walk to Beach/Restaurants/Museums- Village House w/backyard
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.5k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Barbecue, Crib, Dryer, Fireplace, Fitness Equipment, Free Parking, Heater, Internet

6 Bedrooms14 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

11 reviews

$3237
Average price / night
Check Availability
Cowgirl Palace
Cowgirl Palace
House
Sag Harbor, NY, USA
3.0k from Bay Street Theatre center

Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Homestays, Lodgings, Vacation rentals, Jacuzzis, Places to stay, Family

6 Bedrooms18 Guests
5.9

Review score

19 reviews

$950
Average price / night
Check Availability
Cozy Historical Sag Harbor Village Home - 5 min walk to town, working fireplaces
Cozy Historical Sag Harbor Village Home - 5 min walk to town, working fireplaces
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.5k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Balcony, Barbecue, Dryer, Fireplace, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen

4 Bedrooms8 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

7 reviews

$3358
Average price / night
Check Availability
Heated Pool, Hot tub, Beachwood Cove by RoveTravel
Heated Pool, Hot tub, Beachwood Cove by RoveTravel
House
Bay Street Theatre, Sag Harbor, New York, USA
3.5k from Bay Street Theatre center

Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Villas, Vacation homes, Cottages, Pet-friendly, Lodgings, Vacation rentals

1 Bedroom6 Guests
New to Booking
$805
Average price / night
Check Availability
Charming 4-bedroom house in Sag Harbor
Charming 4-bedroom house in Sag Harbor
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.6k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Fireplace, Free Parking, Heater, Hot Tub, Internet, Kitchen

4 Bedrooms8 Guests
New to Booking
$2710
Average price / night
Check Availability
Villa Charlotte - Elegant 7 Bedroom
Villa Charlotte - Elegant 7 Bedroom
Villa
Bay Street Theatre, Sag Harbor, New York, USA
4.3k from Bay Street Theatre center

Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Villas, Vacation homes, Cottages, Lodgings, Beach, Places to stay

7 Bedrooms14 Guests
New to Booking
$2500
Average price / night
Check Availability
Historic Sag Harbor Village Gem
Historic Sag Harbor Village Gem
Apartment
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.6k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Microwave, No Smoking

1 Bedroom2 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

90 reviews

$599
Average price / night
Check Availability
Villa Azeeka - Luxury with pool
Villa Azeeka - Luxury with pool
Villa
Bay Street Theatre, Sag Harbor, New York, USA
4.8k from Bay Street Theatre center

Luxury, Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Villas, Vacation homes, Cottages, Lodgings, Vacation rentals

7 Bedrooms14 Guests
New to Booking
$2291
Average price / night
Check Availability
Sag Harbor Historic Village Home w/ Pool; 2 min walk to the heart of the Village
Sag Harbor Historic Village Home w/ Pool; 2 min walk to the heart of the Village
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.6k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Fireplace, Fitness Equipment, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen

3 Bedrooms6 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

19 reviews

$1435
Average price / night
Check Availability
Sag Harbor Village\nPrivate, 2-bedroom 60's ranch, 5 minute walk to Main Street
Sag Harbor Village\nPrivate, 2-bedroom 60's ranch, 5 minute walk to Main Street
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.7k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Microwave

2 Bedrooms4 Guests
9.4

Superb

21 reviews

$551
Average price / night
Check Availability
SAG VILLAGE RENTAL WITH HEATED POOL - SECONDS WALK TO TOWN, MARINA &HAVENS BEACH
SAG VILLAGE RENTAL WITH HEATED POOL - SECONDS WALK TO TOWN, MARINA &HAVENS BEACH
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.7k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Fireplace, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry

4 Bedrooms6 Guests
New to Booking
$1770
Average price / night
Check Availability
Beautifully Designed Sag Harbor Home with Private Pool, Close to Town and...
Beautifully Designed Sag Harbor Home with Private Pool, Close to Town and...
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.8k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Fireplace, Fitness Equipment, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen

3 Bedrooms6 Guests
New to Booking
$2753
Average price / night
Check Availability
A Happy House in the Village
A Happy House in the Village
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.8k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Fireplace, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry

3 Bedrooms8 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

13 reviews

$1270
Average price / night
Check Availability
Sag Harbor Charmer - 2 Bedroom Cottage; Walk to Town
Sag Harbor Charmer - 2 Bedroom Cottage; Walk to Town
Cottage
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.8k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Living Area, Microwave, No Smoking, Outdoor Space

2 Bedrooms4 Guests
9.6

Exceptional

34 reviews

$719
Average price / night
Check Availability
Breakwater by Rove Travel | 3BR Secluded Retreat
Breakwater by Rove Travel | 3BR Secluded Retreat
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.8k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Balcony, Dryer, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry, Microwave

3 Bedrooms6 Guests
New to Booking
$1144
Average price / night
Check Availability
Beautifully renovated historic home in Sag Harbor Village.  Walk to Everything.
Beautifully renovated historic home in Sag Harbor Village. Walk to Everything.
House
Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, United States
0.8k from Bay Street Theatre center

AC, Barbecue, Dryer, Fireplace, Free Parking, Heater, Internet, Kitchen, Laundry

4 Bedrooms8 Guests
10.0

Exceptional

1 reviews

$1628
Average price / night
Check Availability

Pro Tip:
VacationByOwnerRentals aggregates the best inventory from leading travel sites, including Booking.com, Agoda.com, Expedia.com, Vrbo.com, and Airbnb.com. Use our Advanced Filters to compare verified homes, villas, cabins, condos, cottages, vacation rentals, hotels, and eco-friendly stays. Our goal is to help you find the absolute best Vacation Rentals in Bay Street Theatre.

Where to stay in Bay Street Theatre? Best neighborhoods & areas

Bay Street Theatre Vacation Rentals on the Map

Frequently Asked Questions

You can explore 875 verified vacation rentals in Bay Street Theatre. Our listings are sourced from a range of trusted providers, giving you access to a wide selection of private homes, apartments, and unique stays—all in one place.

Vacation rental prices in Bay Street Theatre vary depending on the season, property size, and location. Rates typically start from around $270 per night, with higher prices for larger homes or peak travel periods. Comparing available options can help you find a stay that matches both your budget and travel plans.

Most vacation rentals in Bay Street Theatre include fully equipped kitchens, making it easy to prepare meals and enjoy a more flexible stay. This is especially useful for families, longer stays, or travelers who prefer a home-like experience.

Yes, many vacation rentals in Bay Street Theatre welcome pets. Currently, 27 listings allow pets, although specific policies may vary by property. You can filter for pet-friendly options to quickly find suitable accommodations.

For popular travel periods such as holidays or peak seasons, it’s recommended to book your vacation rental 60 to 90 days in advance to secure the best options. During quieter times, you may still find good availability closer to your travel dates.

Vacation rentals in Bay Street Theatre often include amenities such as Fireplace/Heating, View, and Internet. These features provide added comfort and convenience, making them a popular choice for travelers seeking more space and privacy.

You can use filters to narrow down your search by criteria such as number of bedrooms, guest ratings, or specific amenities like private pools or beachfront access. This makes it easier to find a property that fits your exact needs and preferences.