Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Spa, Romantic, 3-star, Lodgings, Hot tubs, Places to stay
Very Good
1170 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Romantic, 3-star, Lodgings, Jacuzzis, Places to stay, Accessible hotels
Fabulous
1050 reviews
AC, Bar, Business Services, Crib, Elevator, Extra Bed, Fitness Equipment, Frontdesk 24 Hour, Hot Tub
Superb
3537 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Romantic, Boutique, 3-star, Lodgings, Hot tubs, Places to stay
Fabulous
1270 reviews
AC, Bar, Breakfast Available, Business Services, Elevator, Fitness Equipment, Frontdesk 24 Hour, Hot Tub, Housekeeping
Very Good
1002 reviews
Accommodations, Parking, 3-star, Lodgings, Places to stay
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Lodgings, Places to stay, Accessible hotels
Good
276 reviews
AC, Bar, Elevator, Free Parking, Frontdesk 24 Hour, Housekeeping, Internet, Microwave, Outdoor Space
Review score
1001 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Boutique, 4-star, Lodgings, Places to stay, Accessible hotels
Very Good
158 reviews
AC, Frontdesk 24 Hour, Housekeeping, Internet, No Smoking, Parking Available, Pool, TV
Fabulous
1002 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Ramada, Lodgings, Places to stay, Accessible hotels
Good
451 reviews
AC, Barbecue, Housekeeping, Internet, Microwave, No Smoking, Parking Available, TV
Good
401 reviews
Accommodations, Parking, Hilton , Pet-friendly, 4-star, Lodgings, Places to stay, Family, Accessible hotels
Very Good
394 reviews
Accommodations, Motels, Parking, Pet-friendly, Lodgings, Places to stay, Accessible hotels
Good
845 reviews
B&bs, Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Inns, Pet-friendly, Lodgings, Places to stay, Accessible hotels
Good
199 reviews
AC, Balcony, Breakfast Included, Business Services, Crib, Elevator, Extra Bed, Fitness Equipment, Free Parking
Fabulous
1805 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Romantic, Hilton , Pet-friendly, 3-star, Lodgings, Hot tubs
Superb
379 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Romantic, Hilton , Pet-friendly, 3-star, Lodgings, Hot tubs
Very Good
756 reviews
AC, Airport Transportation, Bar, Breakfast Available, Business Services, Crib, Elevator, Extra Bed, Fitness Equipment
Very Good
1006 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Marriott , 3-star, Lodgings, Hot tubs, Places to stay, Family
Fabulous
273 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Pet-friendly, 3-star, Lodgings, Places to stay, Family, Accessible hotels
Fabulous
896 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Marriott , Pet-friendly, 3-star, Lodgings, Places to stay, Family
Very Good
295 reviews
AC, Bar, Breakfast Available, Business Services, Elevator, Extra Bed, Fitness Equipment, Frontdesk 24 Hour, Hot Tub
Superb
1309 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Romantic, Sheraton, Pet-friendly, 4-star, Lodgings, Hot tubs
Very Good
1105 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, 3-star, Lodgings, Places to stay, Family
Fabulous
254 reviews
Accommodations, Pools, Parking, Lodgings, Places to stay, Accessible hotels
Good
1021 reviews
Accommodations, Motels, Parking, Lodgings, Places to stay, Accessible hotels
Review score
441 reviews
Pro Tip:
VacationByOwnerRentals aggregates the best inventory from leading travel sites, including Booking.com, Agoda.com, Expedia.com, Vrbo.com, and Airbnb.com. Use our Advanced Filters to compare verified homes, villas, cabins, condos, cottages, vacation rentals, hotels, and eco-friendly stays. Our goal is to help you find the absolute best Hotels in Shelter Island.
Some of the best hotels in Shelter Island are:
You can explore 620 verified hotels in Shelter Island. These include a range of options from luxury resorts and boutique hotels to budget-friendly accommodations suitable for different travel styles.
Hotel prices in Shelter Island vary depending on the season, location, and property type. Rates typically start from around $103 per night, with higher prices for premium hotels, central locations, or peak travel dates.
Most hotels in Shelter Island include amenities such as Guest Services, Accessibility, and Wheelchair Accessible. Additional features like breakfast, parking, or resort facilities may vary by property, so it’s helpful to review the details before booking.
You can identify top-rated hotels in Shelter Island by sorting listings based on guest ratings and reviews. Looking at recent feedback, overall scores, and review volume can help you find properties that consistently deliver a high-quality experience.
For popular travel periods or busy locations, booking 30 to 60 days in advance is generally recommended to secure preferred options. During quieter periods, you may find more flexibility and availability closer to your travel dates.
Yes, some hotels in Shelter Island welcome pets. Currently, 28 listings allow pets, although policies may vary. It’s a good idea to review any pet-related rules before booking.
Many hotels in Shelter Island offer flexible or refundable booking options. Checking the cancellation policy before confirming your reservation can help you choose a rate that suits your travel plans.